Nominations are Closed

User avatar
normsherman
Site Admin
Posts: 1355
Joined: Sat Oct 13, 2007 4:58 am

Nominations are Closed

Postby normsherman » Thu Mar 01, 2012 6:31 am

Nominations are closed. Stay tuned for final voting! Time to total up nominations. Any intrepid, spreadsheet loving fan out there who wants to save Uncle Norm some tallying? Post away. I love you.
"Give us all some Jelly"

User avatar
Algernon Sydney is Dead
Moderator
Posts: 3498
Joined: Thu Oct 16, 2008 11:22 pm
Location: PRK (California)

Re: Nominations are Closed

Postby Algernon Sydney is Dead » Thu Mar 01, 2012 2:09 pm

Okay, here are the results for Artwork:

Code: Select all

Episode         Artist                  Nominations
----------      --------------------    -----------
 11             Bo Kaier                     7     
208             Jerel Dye                    7     
119             Bo Kaier                     5     
212             Matt Wasiela                 5     
211             Michael Hoskins              5     
126             Adam S. Doyle                4     
200             Adam S. Doyle                4     
199             Bill Halliar                 4     
115             Bo Kaier                     4     
123             Forrest Warner               4     
216             Jan Dennison                 4     
 98             Matt Wasiela                 4     
 22             Rodolfo Arredondo            4     
 91             Kelly Macavaney              3     
 19             Mary Mattice                 3     
206             Philippa Jones               3     
227             Adam S. Doyle                2     
  2             Bo Kaier                     2     
207             Bo Kaier                     2     
 49             Bo Kaier                     2     
 77             Bo Kaier                     2     
Bsides 15       Bo Kaier                     2     
 39             Brent Holmes                 2     
 21             David Flett                  2     
214             David Flett                  2     
 16             John Deberge                 2     
 55             Mary Mattice                 2     
  6             Matt Schindler               2     
230             Matt Wasiela                 2     
 53             Rick Green                   2     
225             Steve Santiago               2     
201             Alyssa Suzumura              1     
223             Alyssa Suzumura              1     
215             Bo Kaier                     1     
228             Bo Kaier                     1     
 62             Bo Kaier                     1     
 68             Bo Kaier                     1     
 79             Jonathan Wilson              1     
 94             Jonathan Wilson              1     
220             Liz Pennies                  1     
108             Mary Mattice                 1     
 95             Matt Cowens                  1     
210             Matt Schindler               1     
 84             Mike Dominic                 1     
221             Rick Green                   1     
218             Rodolfo Arredondo            1     
196             Sean Azzapardi               1     
226             Skeet Scienski               1     




Code: Select all

Artist                  Nominations
-------------------     -----------
Bo Kaier                    30
Matt Wasiela                11
Adam S. Doyle               10
Jerel Dye                    7
Mary Mattice                 6
Michael Hoskins              5
Rodolfo Arredondo            5
Bill Halliar                 4
David Flett                  4
Forrest Warner               4
Jan Dennison                 4
Kelly Macavaney              3
Matt Schindler               3
Philippa Jones               3
Rick Green                   3
Alyssa Suzumura              2
Brent Holmes                 2
John Deberge                 2
Jonathan Wilson              2
Steve Santiago               2
Liz Pennies                  1
Matt Cowens                  1
Mike Dominic                 1
Sean Azzapardi               1
Skeet Scienski               1




Code: Select all

Episode         Audit list
----------      ----------------------------------------
 11             Algernon Sydney is Dead, behind the ziggurat, Dr. Ew,
                Pookie1864, ranta may, strawman, tbaker2500
208             behind the ziggurat, Discodave, Dolohov, Pookie1864,
                ranta may, samuelvictorwood, StalinSays
119             adonisatreus, behind the ziggurat, Pookie1864, strawman,
                tbaker2500
212             adonisatreus, behind the ziggurat, Dolohov, ranta may,
                samuelvictorwood
211             Algernon Sydney is Dead, Discodave, Dr. Ew, ranta may,
                StalinSays
126             Discodave, Pookie1864, strawman, tbaker2500
200             Dolohov, ranta may, samuelvictorwood, tbaker2500
199             behind the ziggurat, Pookie1864, ranta may, StalinSays
115             Algernon Sydney is Dead, Dr. Ew, ROU Killing Time,
                tbaker2500
123             Algernon Sydney is Dead, Pookie1864, StalinSays,
                tbaker2500
216             adonisatreus, samuelvictorwood, strawman, tbaker2500
 98             behind the ziggurat, Dolohov, Pookie1864, StalinSays
 22             behind the ziggurat, Dr. Ew, StalinSays, strawman
 91             behind the ziggurat, ROU Killing Time, strawman
 19             Dolohov, Dr. Ew, tbaker2500
206             Dolohov, ranta may, tbaker2500
227             Discodave, samuelvictorwood
  2             Algernon Sydney is Dead, ROU Killing Time
207             Algernon Sydney is Dead, tbaker2500
 49             Algernon Sydney is Dead, Pookie1864
 77             Dr. Ew, ranta may
Bsides 15       Algernon Sydney is Dead, Dolohov
 39             Pookie1864, StalinSays
 21             behind the ziggurat, ranta may
214             Dr. Ew, strawman
 16             behind the ziggurat, StalinSays
 55             Pookie1864, strawman
  6             adonisatreus, Dr. Ew
230             Dolohov, samuelvictorwood
 53             adonisatreus, strawman
225             adonisatreus, Discodave
201             StalinSays
223             Dolohov
215             adonisatreus
228             Dolohov
 62             strawman
 68             Dr. Ew
 79             StalinSays
 94             ROU Killing Time
220             adonisatreus
108             ranta may
 95             Algernon Sydney is Dead
210             adonisatreus
 84             ROU Killing Time
221             Dr. Ew
218             adonisatreus
196             samuelvictorwood
226             Algernon Sydney is Dead

User avatar
Algernon Sydney is Dead
Moderator
Posts: 3498
Joined: Thu Oct 16, 2008 11:22 pm
Location: PRK (California)

Re: Nominations are Closed

Postby Algernon Sydney is Dead » Thu Mar 01, 2012 3:20 pm

The results for Drabbles:

Code: Select all

Episode     Author                  Nominations
-------     --------------------    -----------
214         Jessica Broughton            7**     
222         John Murphy                  6     
229         Nicholas J Carter            5     
230         Phenopath                    5     
225         Tesseract McCrea             5     
218         Christopher Munroe           4     
216         Evan Quinlan                 4     
217         Nathan Lee                   3     
198         Peter Diamond                2     
209         Danger Slater                1     
224         Edgar Arthur                 1     
228         Greg Winkler                 1     
215         Steven Lidster               1     

** Several nominations for #214 were "interesting". #216 and # 218 may have been unfairly dropped.



Code: Select all

Author                  Nominations
--------------------    -----------
Jessica Broughton            7
John Murphy                  6
Nicholas J Carter            5
Phenopath                    5
Tesseract McCrea             5
Christopher Munroe           4
Evan Quinlan                 4
Nathan Lee                   3
Peter Diamond                2
Danger Slater                1
Edgar Arthur                 1
Greg Winkler                 1
Steven Lidster               1




Code: Select all

Episode     Audit list
-------     --------------------------------------------------------
214         Beth Peters, christireliv, evergraceful, gluaygluays,
            jbohbot13, sing3withaswing, tbaker2500
222         evergraceful, Grrlwriter, munsi, ROU Killing Time, Scattercat,
            tbaker2500
229         Beth Peters, Discodave, ROU Killing Time, Scattercat,
            StalinSays
230         Beth Peters, Discodave, Grrlwriter, ROU Killing Time,
            Scattercat
225         Discodave, Grrlwriter, Scattercat, StalinSays, tbaker2500
218         Grrlwriter, ROU Killing Time, Scattercat, tbaker2500
216         Discodave, evergraceful, Grrlwriter, StalinSays
217         Beth Peters, munsi, ROU Killing Time
198         Beth Peters, StalinSays
209         munsi
224         StalinSays
228         Discodave
215         tbaker2500

User avatar
strawman
Member
Posts: 5966
Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 2:20 pm
Location: South Georgia

Re: Nominations are Closed

Postby strawman » Thu Mar 01, 2012 4:21 pm

Please explain the screens
Never judge anyone until you have biopsied their brain.

"Be kind, for everyone is fighting a hard battle."
Known Some Call Is Air Am
Spoiler:
Non sum qualis eram = "I am not who I will be"

User avatar
tbaker2500
Site Admin
Posts: 3592
Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2007 7:03 pm
Location: West Lafayette, IN
Contact:

Re: Nominations are Closed

Postby tbaker2500 » Thu Mar 01, 2012 4:35 pm

Nice data, ASID. Thanks!
You're my quasi-ichthian angel, you're my half-amphibian queen...

The Dribblecast, we don't care if you sound like an idiot.

User avatar
Algernon Sydney is Dead
Moderator
Posts: 3498
Joined: Thu Oct 16, 2008 11:22 pm
Location: PRK (California)

Re: Nominations are Closed

Postby Algernon Sydney is Dead » Thu Mar 01, 2012 4:42 pm

Results for Story:

Code: Select all

Episode  Author(s)                                            Nominations
-------  ------------------------------------------------     -----------
214      Eugie Foster                                             16     
206      Ramsey Shehadeh                                          12     
202/203  Elizabeth Bear and Sarah Monette                         10     
217      Will McIntosh                                            10     
225      Amanda C. Davis, Megan R. Engelhard, Steven Saus          7     
226      Elise R. Hopkins                                          7     
198      Jessica Grant                                             7     
230      Terry Bisson                                              7     
211      Nick Mamatas                                              6     
218      Susan Forest                                              6     
222      Aubrey Hirsch                                             5     
205      Sandra Odell, J.R. Hamantaschen, Nicky Drayden            5     
208      Aidan Doyle                                               4     
221      An Owomoyela                                              4     
216      Mike Resnick                                              4     
210      Tim Pratt, Heather Shaw, Greg van Eekhout, Jen Reese      3     
209      Aliya Whiteley                                            2     
199      James S. Dorr                                             2     
197      Mary Robinette Kowal                                      2     
219      George R. Galuschak                                       1     
224      John P. Murphy                                            1     
215      Kristine Kathryn Rusch                                    1     
212      Michael Swanwick                                          1     
223      Nikki Alfar                                               1     
220      Richard Weems, Andrew Gudgel, Nathaniel Tower             1     
201      Sarah Monette, Jens Rushing, Karen Hueler                 1     
207      Stellan Thorne                                            1     
204      Tina Connolly                                             1     
229      Will Ludwigsen                                            1     




Code: Select all

Author(s)                                               Nominations
-------------------------------------------------       -----------
Eugie Foster                                                16
Ramsey Shehadeh                                             12
Elizabeth Bear and Sarah Monette                            10
Will McIntosh                                               10
Amanda C. Davis, Megan R. Engelhard, Steven Saus             7
Elise R. Hopkins                                             7
Jessica Grant                                                7
Terry Bisson                                                 7
Nick Mamatas                                                 6
Susan Forest                                                 6
Aubrey Hirsch                                                5
Sandra Odell, J.R. Hamantaschen, Nicky Drayden               5
Aidan Doyle                                                  4
An Owomoyela                                                 4
Mike Resnick                                                 4
Tim Pratt, Heather Shaw, Greg van Eekhout and Jen Reese      3
Aliya Whiteley                                               2
James S. Dorr                                                2
Mary Robinette Kowal                                         2
George R. Galuschak                                          1
John P. Murphy                                               1
Kristine Kathryn Rusch                                       1
Michael Swanwick                                             1
Nikki Alfar                                                  1
Richard Weems, Andrew Gudgel, Nathaniel Tower                1
Sarah Monette, Jens Rushing, Karen Hueler                    1
Stellan Thorne                                               1
Tina Connolly                                                1
Will Ludwigsen                                               1




Code: Select all

Episode  Audit list
-------  ----------------------------------------------------
214      adonisatreus, alhilton, Althalas, billiam, Discodave,
         Djinndustries, Grrlwriter, Polecat, ranta may, samuelvictorwood,
         StalinSays, strawman, tbaker2500, themorg, THX0785, TimoBretten
206      Althalas, batman3030, Beth Peters, Discodave, emily, Fantomex,
         ROU Killing Time, samuelvictorwood, Scattercat, shagin,
         tbaker2500, undergroundanansi
202/203  alhilton, batman3030, behind the ziggurat, Beth Peters,
         Fantomex, samuelvictorwood, shagin, tbaker2500, themorg,
         TimoBretten
217      adonisatreus, alhilton, behind the ziggurat, Fantomex,
         ranta may, ROU Killing Time, samuelvictorwood, Scattercat,
         tbaker2500, undergroundanansi
225      adonisatreus, alhilton, behind the ziggurat, billiam, Fantomex,
         StalinSays, THX0785
226      alhilton, behind the ziggurat, emily, Scattercat, StalinSays,
         THX0785, TimoBretten
198      Beth Peters, Djinndustries, Fantomex, ROU Killing Time,
         strawman, themorg, THX0785
230      Beth Peters, billiam, Discodave, munsi, Scattercat, shagin,
         themorg
211      Beth Peters, billiam, Djinndustries, emily, StalinSays, strawman
218      batman3030, emily, munsi, Polecat, samuelvictorwood, shagin
222      batman3030, Grrlwriter, munsi, ROU Killing Time, TimoBretten
205      Althalas, ranta may, shagin, StalinSays, undergroundanansi
208      Althalas, billiam, Discodave, emily
221      Djinndustries, Grrlwriter, ranta may, undergroundanansi
216      adonisatreus, batman3030, ranta may, ROU Killing Time
210      Discodave, Grrlwriter, undergroundanansi
209      munsi, Polecat
199      Althalas, strawman
197      Polecat, strawman
219      behind the ziggurat
224      tbaker2500
215      adonisatreus
212      themorg
223      TimoBretten
220      Grrlwriter
201      Djinndustries
207      Polecat
204      Scattercat
229      munsi

User avatar
Algernon Sydney is Dead
Moderator
Posts: 3498
Joined: Thu Oct 16, 2008 11:22 pm
Location: PRK (California)

Re: Nominations are Closed

Postby Algernon Sydney is Dead » Thu Mar 01, 2012 4:56 pm

strawman wrote:Please explain the screens

They're the same as last year:
  1. The first table shows the story or art ranked by number of nominations.
  2. The second table shows an author's total nominations over all stories. A reliable on-base hitter should get love just like the occasional, juiced-up slugger. :)
  3. The 3rd table just lists the forum members that voted per story. It's useful to cross check in case my scripts or I made errors. For every 10 nominations the story was specified 15 different ways in plain text! :!:

    This table had to be split from the first only because this forum wraps code!
  4. The tables are pre-formatted text because the forum does not support HTML tables.

tbaker2500 wrote:Nice data, ASID. Thanks!

You're welcome. Although it wouldn't be too much harder to write a proper voting app. Parsing free-form data is fun the first time, but ...

User avatar
strawman
Member
Posts: 5966
Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 2:20 pm
Location: South Georgia

Re: Nominations are Closed

Postby strawman » Thu Mar 01, 2012 6:35 pm

It would be fun to have a B-Sides award ceremony, with Connor Choadsworth doing Ryan Seacrest on the red carpet. ("Who are you wearing?" would have a new meaning. It could have a 3 hour extravaganza with awards for best parasite, best alien in a supporting role, technical awards for website categories (Bo accepting and thanking Tom, followed by Tom accepting and thanking Bo), best Voice Artist; with live coverage of the proceedings on the Dribblecast, and JLo singing "Everybody's Got Nipples".

That would be parodyse.
Never judge anyone until you have biopsied their brain.

"Be kind, for everyone is fighting a hard battle."
Known Some Call Is Air Am
Spoiler:
Non sum qualis eram = "I am not who I will be"

User avatar
StalinSays
Beast-Master
Posts: 1709
Joined: Sat Oct 13, 2007 4:58 am
Location: West Los Angeles, CA
Contact:

Re: Nominations are Closed

Postby StalinSays » Thu Mar 01, 2012 7:29 pm

Mega-Thanks ASiD for the numbers!

My intention for the final field of Cover Art of the year contenders is one entry per artist - Matt and I will be tethered to our lead vote generator. A tie-breaker is in store for that final spot in the top 5 covers. I've made a poll, I'd appreciate it if you all voted with haste, so that we can gather the finalists for the official vote post haste.
Instagram: @Bokaier | Twitter: @BoKaier | Vine: @BoKaier | Tumblr: bokaier.tumblr.com

User avatar
StalinSays
Beast-Master
Posts: 1709
Joined: Sat Oct 13, 2007 4:58 am
Location: West Los Angeles, CA
Contact:

Re: Nominations are Closed

Postby StalinSays » Thu Mar 01, 2012 9:09 pm

We may need a tie-breaker vote for Best Story too. ASiD - with the episode 225 votes, were you counting collectively for the whole trifecta? David is Six, Best Boy, Brightest Boy, or Broken would have to reach 8 votes individually to qualify for the 5th slot.

It would seem the trio of 226 by Elise R. Hopkins, 198 by Jessica Grant, and 230 by Terry Bisson need a tie-breaker vote. Yes?
Instagram: @Bokaier | Twitter: @BoKaier | Vine: @BoKaier | Tumblr: bokaier.tumblr.com

User avatar
Algernon Sydney is Dead
Moderator
Posts: 3498
Joined: Thu Oct 16, 2008 11:22 pm
Location: PRK (California)

Re: Nominations are Closed

Postby Algernon Sydney is Dead » Thu Mar 01, 2012 11:06 pm

StalinSays wrote:We may need a tie-breaker vote for Best Story too. ASiD - with the episode 225 votes, were you counting collectively for the whole trifecta? David is Six, Best Boy, Brightest Boy, or Broken would have to reach 8 votes individually to qualify for the 5th slot.

It would seem the trio of 226 by Elise R. Hopkins, 198 by Jessica Grant, and 230 by Terry Bisson need a tie-breaker vote. Yes?


With all the tri and bi-fectas, a vote for any one of the stories counted as a vote for the whole episode. I thought that was the intent and it seems a bit much to split out a story that couldn't even carry a whole episode by itself. :P

In the case of episode 225, the semi-parsed vote text is:

Code: Select all

adonisatreus            225 - David Is Six by Amanda C. Davis and/or The
                        Best Boy, The Brightest Boy by Megan R. Engelhard
                        and/or Broken by Steven Saus
alhilton                225 - The Best Boy, The Brightest Boy by Megan R.
                        Engelhard
behind the ziggurat     The Best Boy, The Brightest Boy
billiam                 The Best Boy, The Brightest Boy
Fantomex                The Best Boy, The Brightest Boy
StalinSays              The Best Boy, The Brightest Boy
THX0785                 225 - The Best Boy, The Brightest Boy by Megan R.
                        Engelhard
THX0785                 225 - David Is Six by Amanda C. Davis


Seven votes for The Best Boy, The Brightest Boy, but THX0785 double voted! :oops:

So, Ep 225 actually only got 7 votes -- or minus 552 votes if the proper penalty for voting errors is applied. :twisted:

I corrected the table above and checked all 3 audits. Story #225 was the only place where the same user ID was counted twice (not counting potential sock puppets).

User avatar
StalinSays
Beast-Master
Posts: 1709
Joined: Sat Oct 13, 2007 4:58 am
Location: West Los Angeles, CA
Contact:

Re: Nominations are Closed

Postby StalinSays » Thu Mar 01, 2012 11:32 pm

So then best path would be a four way tie-breaker vote between 226 by Elise R. Hopkins, 198 by Jessica Grant, 230 by Terry Bisson, and 225 by Megan R. Engelhard {individually}

PS: I am not after a full audit, I just want to be sure we aren't slighting a rightful finalist when deciding the nomination by 1 vote. Your totals are super-duper appreciated times a million.

I'll create the topic. That is to say Norm will.
Instagram: @Bokaier | Twitter: @BoKaier | Vine: @BoKaier | Tumblr: bokaier.tumblr.com

User avatar
THX0785
Member
Posts: 7
Joined: Wed Feb 22, 2012 5:53 pm
Location: Pennsylvania
Contact:

Re: Nominations are Closed

Postby THX0785 » Tue Mar 06, 2012 9:39 pm

I was thinking that the voting was for the individual stories. It didn't make much sense to me that it would be per episode since that would mean that if one story in a trifecta was the winner, 3 writers and 3 stories would get the award.
"If it's not EPIC, it's not worth doing."

User avatar
Algernon Sydney is Dead
Moderator
Posts: 3498
Joined: Thu Oct 16, 2008 11:22 pm
Location: PRK (California)

Re: Nominations are Closed

Postby Algernon Sydney is Dead » Tue Mar 06, 2012 10:41 pm

Yeah, no biggie; there was some confusion on that point and I'm still not sure we're all on the same page.

It turns out that, this year, it doesn't matter as the results are the same once the edge case was caught and corrected for. This time, per-story versus per-episode (The way the almighty God intended) both yield identical outcomes once the double vote was accounted for.

User avatar
StalinSays
Beast-Master
Posts: 1709
Joined: Sat Oct 13, 2007 4:58 am
Location: West Los Angeles, CA
Contact:

Re: Nominations are Closed

Postby StalinSays » Tue Mar 06, 2012 10:55 pm

Update: Final list is set. Waiting on Norm to finish up episode 235, which includes the announcement. Then we'll be opening up the 2 weeks of People's Choice voting.
Instagram: @Bokaier | Twitter: @BoKaier | Vine: @BoKaier | Tumblr: bokaier.tumblr.com


Return to “2011 Drabblecast People's Choice Awards”



Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest

cron